-HEARTY CONGRATULATIONS TO MY LORD, HON. JUSTICE JAMES OMOTOSHO, ON HIS ELEVATION AND SWEARING-IN AS A JUSTICE OF THE COURT OF APPEAL
Ascending the ladder of the Bench, particularly from the vantage point of an active litigation practitioner who has traversed the rudiments of legal practice, from criminal litigation to active prosecution, before eventual elevation to the Bench, affords a judicial officer an invaluable breadth of practical experience and a panoramic appreciation of the demands of legal practice, which ought to find meaningful expression in judicial adjudication.
This, in my considered view, is what judicial appointments ought to embody: a judicial officer who has painstakingly traversed the intricacies of legal practice. Regrettably, some recent appointments to the Bench appear to have departed substantially from this invaluable trajectory, leaving active litigation practitioners and, regrettably, litigants at the receiving end. This, however, is a subject for another day.
In December 2022, when over 50 promising young Igbo men and women, including young mothers and fathers, were rounded up at a funeral ceremony in Anambra State, South-East Nigeria, mischievously branded and categorised as IPOB members, and consequently subjected to excruciating torture, prolonged incarceration and degrading treatment before being ferried to Abuja, where they endured another round of brutal torture, some were reportedly chained by their legs and hanged. In the tragic circumstances, Ndi Igbo lost three able-bodied young men who had committed no offence known to law, other than being Igbo and belonging to an ethnic group that appeared to have been earmarked for collective persecution under the then despotic Buhari administration. I took it upon myself to vigorously advocate their cause and pursue every lawful avenue to secure their freedom. That advocacy was not without fierce courtroom battles.
They were subsequently charged with a litany of grave offences, including acts of terrorism, membership of proscribed organisations and other weighty allegations. These seemingly formidable charges, carrying the prospect of severe punishment, appeared calculated to ensure their prolonged incarceration, notwithstanding the paucity of credible evidence establishing their culpability. To say the least, the charges appeared to be predicated on an unfortunate and dangerous ethnic profiling.
I nevertheless assured their distressed relatives that they had cause to thank God that we had eventually discovered where their loved ones were being detained and that the Buhari administration had, at last, allowed them to be brought before a court of competent jurisdiction.
They were eventually arraigned before the Federal High Court, Abuja, on the aforementioned grave charges, and the matter was assigned to my Lord, the Honourable Justice James Omotosho.
My first appearance before His Lordship in that matter initially left me with an erroneous impression that the court was hostile towards me, my team and the defendants. How mistaken I was! My Lord turned out to be an exceptionally diligent, proactive and knowledgeable judicial officer, particularly in the intricate field of criminal adjudication. Having listened attentively to the harrowing circumstances surrounding these young men and women, His Lordship ordered an accelerated hearing.
The proceedings were indeed intellectually engaging, bordering on a rigorous exposition of the very intricacies and nitty-gritty of criminal jurisprudence. The prosecution called approximately seven witnesses in proof of its case, all of whom were subjected to exhaustive cross-examination by our team. At the conclusion of the prosecution’s case, we considered it imperative to file a no-case submission, predicated on the manifest deficiencies and porous nature of the evidence led, which, in our professional assessment, could not sustain the weighty charges preferred against these innocent Igbo defendants.
I was particularly touched by the palpable apprehension expressed by the defendants’ relatives, who were visibly unsettled by my Lord’s non-Igbo background and other considerations, however immaterial, and consequently feared that justice might not be done. Some had already begun to suspect foul play. However, I had the confidence that if the law, as we had painstakingly espoused and demonstrated throughout the trial, was allowed to prevail, justice would undoubtedly be done in favour of the defendants. I had no such negative apprehension about His Lordship.
When the date for the ruling on our no-case submission eventually arrived, the atmosphere in court was palpably charged. As was customary in the circumstances, the entire court premises had been cordoned off by a formidable contingent of police officers, military personnel and operatives of the Department of State Services (DSS).
His Lordship delivered an extensive and meticulously reasoned ruling, critically evaluating the evidence led by the prosecution, its probative value and its legal relevance to the charges preferred. In a resounding affirmation of the supremacy of the law, His Lordship upheld our no-case submission and accordingly discharged and acquitted these young Igbo men and women of all the frivolous yet grave charges brought against them.
My Lord did not stop there. In a remarkable demonstration of judicial compassion and practical commitment to the liberty of the citizen, His Lordship immediately directed the prison authorities to await and collect the discharge warrants to facilitate their prompt release from custody.
Visibly moved by the circumstances of the defendants, His Lordship further directed his court clerk to arrange for bottled water to be made available to all the defendants, such a seemingly modest gesture spoke volumes about the extraordinary humanity behind the judicial robe.
The young Igbo defendants were consequently released without delay. Indeed, upon their arrival at the Kuje Correctional Centre that same day, the officer in charge reportedly refused them entry into the facility on the ground that they had already been discharged and released from lawful custody.
My Lord, as you embark upon this next and exalted chapter of your judicial career, may the Almighty God continue to strengthen you in the discharge of this noble responsibility, elevate you to even greater heights and preserve you in wisdom, courage and unwavering fidelity to the rule of law.
You have demonstrated, in a defining moment, that justice must know no tribe, religion or prejudice; for the law, when faithfully administered, remains the greatest equaliser of humanity. As the age-old wisdom reminds us, the palm tree does not bend its branches to one particular direction when the wind blows. May your judicial legacy continue to affirm that the scales of justice must remain blind to ethnicity but responsive to the dictates of law and conscience.
Posterity shall indeed be kind to you, my noble Lord.
Hearty congratulations once again, My Lord!
Signed:
Sir Ifeanyi Ejiofor, Esq. (KSC)
Dunu-Ezeugosinachi
18th November, 2026
